Imagine two people walking two different paths.

Two paths, two outcomes

The first person engages in crime. They are caught and spend time in prison. A competent lawyer protects them by claiming a mental health issue. When they get out, they receive a government package to support their mental health. They successfully manipulate the disability support system. And they live like a queen, with all their affairs taken care of by government support.

The second person works hard throughout life. They retire from service. They struggle with health issues. They barely get any support from the government. They struggle financially to support themselves through old age. And life is misery.

If we judged only by where each person ended up, we would have to conclude that the first path was the better one.

No one believes that. Yet this is exactly how we judge most of the time.

The example is deliberately extreme. It is not a comment on the many people who rely on support they genuinely need. It is a test of how we judge.

We judge actions by their outcome

Often we judge actions from the outcome.

The project that came in on budget was well led. The one that failed was badly run. The investment that paid off was a smart call. The person who ended up comfortable must have done something right. The person who is struggling must have done something wrong.

It has a name: outcome bias. We look at the result and work backwards to a verdict on the decision.

Perhaps the outcome is not a reliable indicator at all. As I wrote recently, results are the wrong judge.

Virtue and luck are not the same thing

Doing the right thing is a virtue.

Getting a favourable outcome is luck.

The first is ours. We choose it, and we own it. The second depends on things we do not control. The lawyer we can afford. How a system happens to work. Our health. Timing. The people who cross our path.

When we mix the two, we start rewarding luck as if it were virtue, and punishing misfortune as if it were a failure of character. Luck can speed up what the work has set in motion. It cannot tell us whether the work was right.

Judging is mere speculation

Judging from actions and outcomes is mere speculation.

We see a fragment of someone’s path. We see where they are today, and we fill in the rest with our own story. We rarely see what they faced, what they gave up, or what they chose not to do.

Life is not a straight line

Drawing conclusions from a linear hypothesis is childish.

Do good, get good. Do wrong, get punished. It is a comforting idea, and it is how we explain the world to children. But it does not hold up against the two paths above, and it does not hold up against most of what we see around us.

Life is much more complex, surprising and thrilling than we think.

Which means the right thing has to be worth doing for its own sake. Not because of what it will get us.

The questions that remain

Here are some questions to ponder.

The last time you called a decision good, were you judging the decision or the result?

If the right thing led to the worse outcome, would you still choose it?

And if outcomes are partly luck, what are you actually proud of?

Customer Experience

DOWNLOAD THIS EXCLUSIVE EBOOK!

Learn why awesome Customer Experience Is Necessity?

Struggling To Win New Customers? Revealing No.1 Culprit!

Exposing Hidden Complexities Of PreSales

5 Step Process To Improve Customer Experience

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Share This