By nature, whatever goes up will come down, and the reverse is also true.
We see it everywhere. Day turns to night. Summer gives way to winter. The tide comes in and goes out. A tree drops its leaves in autumn and grows them back in spring. None of us calls winter a failure. We know it is part of the cycle.
We cheer the rise and fear the fall
Yet when it comes to our own lives and organisations, we forget this. We like it when things go up, and we declare failure when they come down.
A business has a record year, and the next year sales dip. Panic. House prices climb for a decade, then fall. The headlines call it a crisis. A career rises quickly, then levels off. We wonder what we did wrong.
What we fail to realise is that the curve that is going up must come down, possibly to come back up again. The fall is not the end of the story. Often, it is the part that makes the next rise possible.
The expectation of endless growth
In democracies and other public organisations, the main goal remains to be profitable. The curve must keep growing.
Economies are measured on growth every quarter. Companies are judged on whether this year beat last year. Every report is expected to show more than the one before it. A flat line is treated as a problem. A falling line is treated as a disaster.
But we are unwilling to accept that things cannot keep heading up all the time. Nothing in nature does.
Two costs, and we pay one of them
There is a cost in accepting negative cycles. Sales fall. Budgets are cut. Plans are put on hold. Sometimes jobs are lost. It is uncomfortable, and nobody wants to be the one in charge when the line points down.
There is also a cost in deferring them, by artificially inflating demand and using other manipulation techniques.
We have all seen these at work. The shop that runs a “sale” every week until no one will pay full price again. The product designed to wear out or go out of date, so we buy another one. Easy credit that lets us buy today what we will pay for over years. Marketing that creates a fear of missing out on something nobody needed last month.
These techniques keep the line pointing up a little longer. They do not remove the downswing. They push it further out, and the demand they created was never real to begin with. When the fall finally comes, it is often harder than it would have been.
Seeing the whole curve
The difference lies in what we choose to look at. If we look only at the point where we stand today, a fall looks like failure. If we look at the whole curve, it looks like a season.
As I wrote recently, every swing to an extreme is a search for balance. The downswing is part of that balancing. And how we respond to it matters as much as the swing itself. When things are going well, we tend to grow rigid; when they go badly, we lose our footing. Perhaps the practice is to be fluid in comfort and stable in challenge.
The questions that remain
Where are you on your curve right now?
Are you treating a natural downswing as a failure?
And what is it costing you to keep the line pointing up?
